Skip To Content
Law & Informality Insights

Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa

By , , , , on August 09, 2021

This edition of Law and Informality Insights analyzes the implications for informal workers of the recent African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights’ (ACHPR) advisory opinion, which was delivered in response to a continental challenge against vagrancy laws on the grounds that they violate several human rights that are enshrined in binding regional instruments.

In this brief, we first outline the decision of the court, bringing attention to aspects of the advisory opinion that informal workers can use in their struggle for access to public space for trading and other livelihood activities. We then consider the orthodox narratives that inform how public space is conceptualized and regulated, and the competing interests of informal workers on the one hand, and the elite on the other. Finally, we argue that this advisory serves as a useful precedent to challenge notions of criminality associated with legitimate street activities and can help in shifting the narratives dominating regulation of public space.

View list of all: Law & Informality Insights

Download the PDF(this link opens in new window)

Citation Information

Dinesh, Krithika, Broembsen, Marlese v., Madhav, Roopa, Bamu, Pamhidzai H., and Marchiori, Teresa. Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa. WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4, , . WIEGO, 2021. https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdfDinesh, K., Broembsen, M. v., Madhav, R., Bamu, P. H., and Marchiori, T. (2021). Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa. WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4, , . https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdfDinesh, Krithika, Broembsen, Marlese v., Madhav, Roopa, Bamu, Pamhidzai H., and Marchiori, Teresa. "Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa." WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4, WIEGO, 2021, .Dinesh Krithika, Broembsen Marlese v., Madhav Roopa, Bamu Pamhidzai H., and Marchiori Teresa. "Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa." WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4 (2021). https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdfDinesh, K, Broembsen, M v, Madhav, R, Bamu, P H, and Marchiori, T 2021, 'Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa', WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4, , . https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdfKrithika Dinesh, Marlese v Broembsen, Roopa Madhav, Pamhidzai H Bamu, and Teresa Marchiori, 'Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa' (2021) WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4 Dinesh K., Broembsen M. v., Madhav R., Bamu P. H., and Marchiori T. Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa. WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4. 2021. https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdfDinesh, Krithika, Broembsen, Marlese v., Madhav, Roopa, Bamu, Pamhidzai H., and Marchiori, Teresa. Re-examining Legal Narratives on Vagrancy, Public Spaces and Colonial Constructs: A Commentary on the ACHPR’s Advisory Opinion on Vagrancy Laws in Africa. WIEGO Law & Informality Insights No. 4. 2021. , . https://www.wiego.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/WIEGO_LawNewsletter_August 2021.pdf

The WIEGO Research Library

WIEGO is at the forefront of developing statistics and research to help audiences understand the informal economy. Our library includes over two decades-worth of informal economy research, policy analysis, statistics and documentation of organizing efforts.